Cast of Murder in a Small Town: Full Season 1, 2 & 3 Guide

There’s something about a cozy small-town mystery that keeps viewers coming back — especially when the cast keeps shifting in interesting ways. Fox’s Murder in a Small Town has built a loyal following since its 2024 debut, thanks in part to a rotating door of guest stars and a core ensemble anchored by Rossif Sutherland and Kristin Kreuk.

Main series cast count: 7 ·
Seasons aired: 2 ·
Third season renewal: Confirmed ·
Original network: Fox ·
Lead actor: Rossif Sutherland ·
Filming location: Gibsons, British Columbia

A quick summary of the series fundamentals, from its creator to the setting.

Where is the series Murder in a Small Town filmed?

Filming locations in Gibsons, British Columbia

• The series is filmed on location in Gibsons, British Columbia, a real coastal town north of Vancouver (Wikipedia (collaborative encyclopedia)).
• Gibsons serves as the fictional setting for the show, with local landmarks used for authenticity (Wikipedia (collaborative encyclopedia)).

Other sets and production details

• Production uses both real locations and built sets to create the small-town atmosphere (ScreenRant (TV and film news outlet)).

The implication: The filming location is more than a backdrop — it shapes the show’s character and gives the cast a distinct environment to work in.

Who is in the cast of Murder in a Small Town season 1?

Main cast for season 1

• Rossif Sutherland as Karl Alberg, the lead detective who moves from Minneapolis to Gibsons (Wikipedia (collaborative encyclopedia)).
• Kristin Kreuk as Cassandra Lee, a librarian and love interest introduced in episode 1 (Wikipedia (collaborative encyclopedia)).
• Aaron Douglas as Sid Sokolowski, police sergeant (TV Guide (TV listings authority)).
• Mya Lowe as Corporal Edwina Yen (Wikipedia (collaborative encyclopedia)).
• Fritzy-Klevans Destine as Andy Kendrick (Wikipedia (collaborative encyclopedia)).
• Fiona Vroom as Phyllis Diaz (TV Guide (TV listings authority)).
• Savonna Spracklin as Isabella Harbud (TV Guide (TV listings authority)).

Recurring characters in season 1

• James Cromwell guest stars as George Wilcox in the pilot (ScreenRant (TV and film news outlet)).
• Devon Sawa appears as Gordon Murphy (Wikipedia (collaborative encyclopedia)).
• Stana Katic plays Zoe Strachan (Wikipedia (collaborative encyclopedia)).
• Paula Patton guest stars as Elizabeth Lewis (Wikipedia (collaborative encyclopedia)).
• Noah Reid as Tommy Cummins (Wikipedia (collaborative encyclopedia)).

The pattern: Season 1 relied on both TV veterans (James Cromwell, Stana Katic) and rising names to fill out its mystery-of-the-week format.

Who is the new cast of Murder in a Small Town season 2?

New regular cast members in season 2

• Bethany Brown joins as Laila Jackson, a new regular character (Wikipedia (collaborative encyclopedia)).
• Marci (full name not yet specified) also joins as a new addition to the core cast (ScreenRant (TV and film news outlet)).

Bethany Brown and Marci in season 2

• Both new characters appear from the start of Season 2, with Brown’s Laila Jackson described as a local business owner (ScreenRant (TV and film news outlet)).

The catch: Adding two new regulars while losing one main cast member shifts the team dynamic — the show is expanding its world even as it says goodbye to a familiar face.

Who is not returning to Murder in a Small Town season 2?

Departures from the main cast in season 2

• Mya Lowe (Corporal Edwina Yen) and Fritzy-Klevans Destine (Andy Kendrick) are not listed in the Season 2 main cast on Wikipedia (collaborative encyclopedia).
• Reports from TV Line indicate “Season 2’s big loss will rock the team,” referring to the departure of a core character (ScreenRant (TV and film news outlet)).

Impact of character exits on the story

• With two regulars gone, Karl Alberg’s team is smaller, placing more responsibility on Sid Sokolowski and the new additions (Wikipedia (collaborative encyclopedia)).

The trade-off: Losing two cast members lets the show bring in bigger guest stars for longer arcs, but risks alienating viewers attached to the original team.

Who are the guest stars in Murder in a Small Town episode 2 and One Last Song?

Guest cast in episode 2

• Based on official previews, no specific guest stars have been named for episode 2 yet (ScreenRant (TV and film news outlet)). The episode continues the pilot’s mystery.

Guest actors in episode One Last Song (MST-204)

• Camryn Manheim appears as Jocelyn Tait in Season 2, though it is not confirmed which episode (ScreenRant (TV and film news outlet)).
• Tyler Posey guest stars as Ryan in Season 2, likely in a mid-season episode (ScreenRant (TV and film news outlet)).
• Malcolm-Jamal Warner appears in Season 2 Episode 3, playing a father suspected of his ex-wife’s murder (ScreenRant (TV and film news outlet)).

The implication: Guest star details for individual episodes remain sparse, but the season is clearly stacking high-profile names in pivotal roles.

Is Murder in a Small Town going to have a third season?

Renewal status for season 3

• Fox has officially renewed Murder in a Small Town for a third season (Wikipedia (collaborative encyclopedia)).
• The renewal was confirmed via IMDb and official sources in early 2025 (ScreenRant (TV and film news outlet)).

Expected release timeline

• No official premiere date has been set, but Season 3 is currently in development and expected to air in late 2025 or 2026 (Wikipedia (collaborative encyclopedia)).

The pattern: Fox’s early renewal signals strong confidence in the show’s performance and suggests the core cast — Sutherland and Kreuk — will remain central.

Seven main cast members, one pattern: the core trio returns each season, but the supporting roster rotates significantly between seasons, giving each year a unique ensemble feel.

The takeaway: The series has used its cast as a storytelling tool — growing and contracting the ensemble to match each season’s mystery arc.

For Fox, the calculus behind casting changes is clear: keep the audience engaged with fresh faces while relying on proven leads. The show’s renewal indicates the strategy is working, but the true test will be whether fans warm to the new ensemble in Season 2. The departure of Mya Lowe and Fritzy-Klevans Destine leaves a void that new additions like Bethany Brown must fill.